Private Hire vs. Taxi: Which Is the Better Option for Drivers?

In Singapore’s competitive transport industry, choosing whether to drive a private hire or taxi can significantly affect your income, flexibility, and job satisfaction. Both options have their advantages and drawbacks, and the right choice depends on your preferences, goals, and lifestyle. This article explores the key differences between the two paths to help you make an informed decision.

1. Flexibility and Control Over Working Hours

Flexibility is one of the biggest differences when comparing private hire and taxi. Private hire drivers often enjoy the freedom to choose when they start and end their shifts. This is especially useful for those who prefer working part-time, need to accommodate personal commitments, or simply wish to avoid rush hour traffic.

Taxi drivers, on the other hand, may need to follow stricter working hours, especially if they are renting vehicles from taxi companies with fixed shift requirements. While this structure provides more routine, it can limit the driver’s ability to control their schedule.

For those who value independence, the flexibility of private hire driving may be more appealing.

2. Earnings Potential and Pay Structure

When considering whether to drive a private hire or taxi, understanding how income works is essential. A taxi driver’s income generally comes from metred fares and street-hail passengers. Additionally, the demand tends to be steady throughout the day, and the fare structure is regulated, which ensures a reliable baseline income.

Private hire drivers typically operate through platforms such as Grab, Gojek, or Ryde. These platforms offer dynamic pricing, which means earnings can increase during peak periods. However, there are also platform commissions and incentive conditions to consider. While the potential to earn more is present, it can vary based on time of day and location.

Drivers looking for consistent and predictable income may prefer taxis, while those willing to work at strategic times might benefit more from private hire work.

3. Vehicle Ownership and Maintenance

When it comes to vehicle rental for drivers, the approach varies between taxi and private hire.

Taxi drivers usually rent their vehicles directly from a taxi company, which involves daily rental fees and commissions on fares. They may also need to follow maintenance schedules set by the company, and often have less say in the type of vehicle they use.

Private hire drivers, however, enjoy more flexibility. They can choose to own their car, lease it from a provider, or utilise daily PHV car rental services. This opens up more options and can lead to cost savings if drivers manage their usage efficiently.

Services such as private hire vehicle leasing give drivers the freedom to choose vehicles that suit their needs—whether they want fuel efficiency, comfort, or storage capacity.

4. Regulatory and Licensing Requirements

Source: Today Online

In Singapore, both private hire and taxi drivers must comply with regulations set by the Land Transport Authority (LTA). Taxi drivers need a Taxi Driver’s Vocational Licence (TDVL), while private hire drivers need a Private Hire Car Driver’s Vocational Licence (PDVL).

The training and testing process is fairly similar, covering topics such as road safety, customer service, and fare regulations. Both groups must also ensure that their vehicles meet safety and insurance standards.

The process of obtaining a licence is straightforward for both roles, but those new to the industry should research which path aligns more closely with their long-term goals.

---

When deciding between private hire or taxi, consider your preferred working hours, income expectations, and level of control over your vehicle. A taxi driver’s income may be more stable due to consistent demand and metred fares, but private hire work offers greater freedom, especially when paired with the right private hire leasing arrangement.

Here at Ecube Auto, we support drivers with flexible vehicle rental for drivers across Singapore. Whether you are looking for daily PHV car rental or long-term private hire vehicle leasing, Ecube Auto offers competitive rates, reliable vehicles, and dedicated support to help you succeed.

For more information about our services, please contact us today.

 

 

 

 

BACK